Physical Foaming: Autoclave vs SCF Injection – Which one is better?

Date
2024.06.26
SHARE THIS STORY
Physical Foaming Comparison Autoclave, Chemical Foaming, SCF Injection

The footwear industry is always on the lookout for lighter and more comfortable footwear and now with and added challenge: Sustainability. Physical foaming, a groundbreaking technology, tackles this challenge by introducing tiny gas bubbles into the midsole material. This incredible technique reduces weight while maintaining or even improving performance. However, within the realm of physical foaming, two main contenders are competing for dominance: Autoclave and SCF (Supercritical Fluid) Injection. In this article, we’ll explore the strengths and weaknesses of each method, empowering you to choose the ultimate champion for your lightweight midsole needs.

Understanding Physical Foaming

Physical foaming involves using a blowing agent, usually a gas, to create a cellular structure within the midsole polymer. This process decreases the material’s overall density, resulting in a significantly lighter end product. There are two primary categories of blowing agents:

1. Chemical Blowing Agents (CBAs): These agents decompose during processing, releasing gas to form foam.
2. Physical Blowing Agents (PBAs): In SCF Injection inert gases like nitrogen (N2) are dissolved into the polymer under high pressure. When the pressure is released, the gas escapes, forming the foam structure.

Autoclave Foaming: The Tried and Recognized Method

Autoclave foaming has a long and impressive history in physical foaming. Here’s how it works:

1. Pre-expansion: The polymer pellets are thoroughly saturated with the CBA under high pressure.
2. Molding: The pre-expanded pellets are then injected strategically into the mold cavity.
3. Autoclave Treatment: The mold, a seasoned warrior, enters a pressurized chamber (autoclave) filled with hot steam or water. The heat activates the CBA, causing it to decompose and release gas. This gas expands, creating the desired foam structure within the molded part.

Advantages of Autoclave Foaming:

– Well-Established: Autoclave foaming is a mature technology with readily available equipment, making it a familiar choice.

Disadvantages of Autoclave Foaming:

– Environmental Concerns: CBAs can be environmentally hazardous, requiring special handling and disposal, adding complexity to the process.
– Multi-Step Complexity: The multi-step process necessitates additional equipment and can be time-consuming, affecting efficiency.
– Limited Control: The properties of the CBA largely dictate the foaming process, offering less control over cell size and density, potentially impacting consistency.
– Inconsistent Quality: Variations in pressure and temperature during autoclave treatment can lead to inconsistencies in the final product, affecting performance.

 

Disadvantages of Autoclave Foaming

 

Introducing the SCF Injection Champion: GENTREX with Mucell® Technology

Supercritical Fluid (SCF) injection with Mucell technology is a more recent and advanced physical foaming method. Let’s see how GENTREX, armed with nitrogen (N2), approaches the battlefield:

1. SCF N2 Saturation: N2 gas strategically infiltrates the molten polymer at high pressure and temperature, surpassing its critical point. This creates a supercritical fluid (SCF) N2 that efficiently dissolves into the polymer.
2. Molding: The N2-saturated polymer is swiftly injected into the mold cavity.
3. Pressure Release: Once inside the mold, the pressure is strategically released. The dissolved N2 escapes from the solution and expands, creating the coveted

Choosing the Right Champion: Aligning with Sustainability Goals

So, when it comes to making lightweight midsoles, there are a few things to consider:

Environmental Regulations: If being eco-friendly is a big deal for you, then SCF with N2 is the winner here. It’s all about keeping things green.

Desired Product Properties: SCF gives you more control over things like cell size and density. That means you can make midsoles that are lighter and perform better. Pretty cool, right?

Budget: Of course, you’ll want to think about the cost. Consider the initial investment and the technical expertise needed for each method.

Sustainability Commitment: It’s important to keep up with the sustainability trend. Nike, Adidas, On, Decathlon, and Brooks are leading the way in eco-friendly practices. If you want to join the club, SCF with N2 and GENTREX are strong contenders. They focus on recyclable and reusable materials, which is a big win for the environment.

GENTREX compare to EVA Injection and Auto Clave

Partnering with the Sustainable Champion: GENTREX SCF Injection

Tien Kang is all about sustainable footwear production, and they proudly offer GENTREX SCF Injection with Mucell® technology. With GENTREX, you can create innovative, high-performance footwear that aligns with the industry’s sustainability goals. Here’s what sets GENTREX apart:

Reduced Manpower: GENTREX takes the load off your shoulders by minimizing the need for manpower. That means lower production costs overall.

Material Sustainability: GENTREX is committed to using recyclable and reusable materials. They’re all about that circular economy and reducing their environmental impact.

Production Efficiency: GENTREX has got your back when it comes to efficiency. They offer multi-station and rotary automation options to optimize production and reduce waste.

 

The Final Verdict

Physical foaming is a game-changer for making lightweight midsoles. But which method is right for you? It all depends on your needs and priorities. Autoclave foaming is still a trustable option. But if you want a more sustainable, efficient, and precise approach, SCF injection with Mucell® technology (like GENTREX) is the way to go. You’ll end up with superior lightweight midsoles.

Physical Foaming Comparison Autoclave, Chemical Foaming, SCF Injection

Ready to Embrace Sustainability and Innovation?

Tien Kang and their expertise in GENTREX SCF Injection with Mucell® technology are here to help you make cutting-edge, sustainable footwear. Get in touch with us today and let’s talk about how we can take your midsole production to the next level and help you achieve your sustainability goals.

To understand more about SCF Injection Please check the following link: https://www.tienkang.com.tw/gentrex/